Backstory: Quantum cake à la Solvay

A Q&A with Pippa Storey, Quantum Shorts finalist

Read the story: Quantum cake à la Solvay

Can you give a short introduction of yourself?

I received a master’s degree in physics from the University of Auckland in New Zealand and a doctorate in quantum physics from the Université Pierre et Marie Curie in France. I am now a Research Associate Professor of Radiology at the New York University School of Medicine, where I develop techniques for MRI.

 

I have always loved reading but rarely, if ever, heard the voices of scientists and mathematicians represented in literature. During the pandemic, I decided to try writing some fiction of my own. To date, I’ve had two other stories published. Links to those stories, plus some of my videos and MRI-based digital artwork, are available on my personal webpage: https://sites.google.com/view/pippastorey

 

How did you come up with the idea for your story?

I started with the last line and riffed on that. It was only after I’d submitted the story that I discovered where the last line probably came from. I’d published a paper in Nature in 1994 with Sze Tan, Matthew Collett and Dan Walls, which addressed the question of whether complementarity is an independent component of quantum mechanics or simply a consequence of Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. Our paper was discussed by the science journalist David Bradley in his 2007 piece Two Slits Are Better Than One. In it, he wrote “Somehow, you can have your quantum cake and eat it”. In retrospect, I suspect that I must have read his article at some point and subconsciously remembered that sentence.

 

Was it difficult to write in rhyme and keep to the syllable count?

If I made it sound difficult, then I haven’t written good verse! (Although making it sound easy is very hard.) Adhering to the meter is more challenging than finding a perfect rhyme. However, it’s also more important, as I illustrate below:

        Poor meter is surely the curse

        Of anyone writing in verse.

        A couplet is fine

        If it doesn’t quite rhyme,

        But if it doesn’t scan that’s much worse!

 

What was your quantum inspiration?

I’ve always been fascinated by the mind-bending aspects of quantum mechanics and the challenges that the theory poses to our fundamental notions of physical reality. I’ve also enjoyed reading about the physicists who developed it, some of whom were very colourful characters. My story contains an incoherent mixture of quantum concepts, superposed with a few historical (and not-so-historical) facts.

 

What was your writing process like?

Writing fiction is just another example of the creative process that must be familiar to all scientists. Ideas come to you in the middle of the night or while you’re taking a walk or having a shower – any time that your mind is free to drift and make associations. You develop them on paper, then scrap most of them, think of some more, and keep iterating until you reach a steady state.

 

What is your favourite science-inspired book?

The book that’s changed my worldview most profoundly is probably The Tangled Tree by David Quammen. In terms of pure enjoyment, my favourite would be Surely You’re Joking, Mr. Feynman.

 

What does being a Quantum Shorts finalist mean to you?

It’s an opportunity to reach a wider audience and show that scientists have a sense of humour.

 

Is there anything else you would like to tell us about you or your story?

I applaud the Centre for Quantum Technologies and its partners for their efforts to foster interest in science and understanding of scientific concepts outside the narrow confines of academia. In this time of extreme polarisation, when even science is politicised, such engagement is vital for the welfare of society and the maintenance (or restoration!) of functioning democracy.